Air Traffic Management Editing and Proofreading Services
A controller may say "descend to three thousand" and a pilot read back "descending to three three thousand." If no one notices the extra digit for eleven seconds, the aircraft is briefly at an altitude assigned to another. The resulting occurrence report must reconstruct exactly what was said, what was heard and why the correction took eleven seconds, because a report that concludes "readback error, remedial training given" and goes no further will not prevent the next occurrence.
The documents we edit for Air Traffic Management
We edit the documents air traffic controllers, safety investigators and air traffic service providers produce: mandatory occurrence reports and accounts of losses of separation, analysis of readback and hearback errors, unit safety case documentation, controller training and simulator debriefing material, letters of agreement between adjacent units, guidance on NOTAM drafting, and the safety bulletins issued after an investigation closes. Our editors work on the exact transcript of what was said, compared with what should have happened.
What the editing involves
The reconstruction of the transcript is what makes an occurrence report useful rather than merely filed, and the characteristic failure is a narrative summary that paraphrases what was said instead of quoting it, since paraphrase loses the exact word that caused the error. We revise these reports so that the words spoken and read back are transcribed verbatim from the recording, since "three thousand" and "three three thousand" produce different reports, and a summary stating that "an error occurred in the readback" erases the distinction that matters. The time between the error and its correction is stated in seconds, given that eleven seconds at a busy hour and eleven seconds on a quiet night are different findings about how the error was allowed to persist. Contributing factors are separated from the immediate cause, because a report listing workload, phraseology and equipment as equally weighted causes gives no one a specific matter to correct. Similar-sounding callsigns or clearances active at the same time are named, as many errors arise from two aircraft on frequency with easily confused identifiers. Each recommendation is something a unit can actually implement rather than a general call for vigilance, since vigilance is not a corrective action. The report distinguishes an isolated slip from a pattern, given that the same type of error recurring among different controllers indicates a problem of phraseology or display rather than of an individual. Reports written in this way lead to change when they are closed.
Confidentiality and the limits of our role
All material sent to us is treated in confidence, including safety data, the identities of personnel involved and investigation material. We are editors, not air traffic controllers, safety investigators or regulators, and we offer no opinion on causation, blame or operational procedure. Our role is to ensure that the reconstruction is precise enough to be useful.
Key Air Traffic Management vocabulary
- Narrative paraphrasing what was said
- Transcript reconstructed verbatim
- Three thousand versus three three thousand
- Losing the exact word that caused it
- Time between error and correction
- Eleven seconds at a busy hour
- Eleven seconds on a quiet night
- Contributing factors separated from cause
- Immediate cause identified specifically
- Workload phraseology and equipment weighted equally
- Nothing specific to fix
- Confusable callsigns named
- Two aircraft on frequency at once
- Recommendation that can be implemented
- General call for vigilance
- Vigilance is not a corrective action
- Isolated slip versus a pattern
- Same error type across different controllers
- Phraseology or display problem
- Individual versus systemic finding
- Readback and hearback error
- Loss of separation
- Mandatory occurrence report
- Unit safety case
- Letters of agreement between units
- Simulator debrief material
- NOTAM drafting
- Safety bulletin after investigation
- Recording reviewed for the transcript
- Report closed out and acted on
Air Traffic Management Terminology Check
A short test of specialist terminology. Select the correct answer.
« More Aerospace, Defense and Space editing | All editing services