Military and Armed Forces Editing and Proofreading Services

Every performance evaluation in a file may say the same thing: exceptional leader, unlimited potential, promote ahead of peers. Ninety-two percent of the evaluations written in a cycle may contain some version of that sentence, because a rater who writes anything less is understood to be harming the person rated rather than describing that person accurately. A promotion board reviewing a stack of files in which everyone is exceptional has no real information before it, and the single evaluation that accurately describes average performance reads, by comparison, like a career-ending report.

The documents we edit for Military and Armed Forces

We edit the documents service members and their raters produce for performance evaluation: officer and enlisted evaluation narratives, award and commendation citations, after-action reviews and lessons-learned reports, fitness reports and comment blocks, letters of recommendation for schools and boards, and the counseling documentation that should precede and support an evaluation. Our editors work on writing within a system in which almost everyone is described in the same superlative terms.

What the editing involves

A specific, comparative accomplishment is what gives an evaluation narrative meaning within a system saturated with superlatives, and the characteristic failure is a series of adjectives that could describe anyone the rater has encountered. "Exceptional" and "unlimited potential" give a board nothing to rank against another file using the same words. We revise these documents so that accomplishments are stated with a number, a ranking or a comparison a board can weigh, since "ranked #2 of 34 company commanders in the battalion" tells a board something that "an exceptional company commander" does not. The narrative describes what was actually done rather than the quality it displayed, given that "led a 40-person platoon through a contested river crossing under fire, reorganizing two squads after a casualty, with zero further casualties" conveys more than "demonstrated exceptional leadership under pressure". A weakness or area for development is included honestly where one exists, because an evaluation with no room for growth is read by an experienced board either as describing an exceptional outlier or as written by a rater unwilling to say anything substantive, and only the first reading helps the person rated. The language matches what was observed rather than the maximum the format permits, as inflation of this degree means that the strongest genuine praise and routine praise use identical words. Counseling that should have preceded the evaluation is documented, given that an evaluation without a supporting counseling record appears to a board to have been invented at the deadline. Citations and narratives avoid stock phrases that appear identically in many service members' files, since a board that has read the same sentence forty times ceases to read it. Evaluations written in this way allow a board to distinguish between candidates.

Confidentiality and the limits of our role

All material sent to us is treated in confidence, including performance records, personnel information and career details. We are editors, not commanders, raters or personnel specialists, and we offer no opinion on performance, promotion or career decisions. Our role is to ensure that the narrative states something a board can act upon.

Key Military and Armed Forces vocabulary

Military and Armed Forces Terminology Check

A short test of specialist terminology. Select the correct answer.

Get a Free Estimate

« More Aerospace, Defense and Space editing  |  All editing services